Expressindia> Sports
Group Websites
Expressindia
Indian Express
Financial Express
Screen
Loksatta
Channels
Blogs
Astrology
Shopping
Hotels
Tenders
Classifieds
ExpressQnA


MOST READ

Ads by Google



Font Size - -A +A

Disease of arrogance is taking its toll

Harsha Bhogle

Posted online: Friday , May 02, 2008 at 0204 hrs IST
      

: So the sentencing on Harbhajan is complete, he has retired home to Jalandhar with a fine that is, effectively, more than a hundred times that imposed on Zinedine Zidane for headbutting a player in a World Cup final and everybody is making the right noises about discipline. We have come down heavily on the deed and we have ignored the cause. We are chopping off the leaves and keeping the roots intact. Prevention is better than cure but it seems a boring exercise because it seems to excite no one. And unless we are serious about it, this will not be the last time something like this happens.

I have heard of an enquiry commission being set up. I have heard nothing about educating players on their responsibilities and about the hazards of fame and money. The IPL is going to provide both in plenty and unless it takes upon itself the job of telling a few home truths to young men, it will turn out to be a seductress rather than a provider. Travelling around as I do with the Mumbai Indians, I have had the opportunity to talk to a few people and I suspect the disease of arrogance, and therefore the path to under-performance, is well and truly upon us.

A lot of our cricketers start early in life and since university education is considered unnecessary, and inter-university cricket is long dead, they step into a bubble very early. They are indoctrinated into a brotherhood where cricketers are considered hallowed, where favours are meant to be received as a matter of right and the arrogance that is the inevitable result closes the door to further education. As a result most of our young cricketers, so good at putting bat to ball, know very little else and indeed are woefully unprepared for a life beyond cricket. You would have thought that if there was only one thing they were good at, they would bow before it every morning, pay obeisance to it. But humility is not a very well understood word, I suspect it is not a very popular way of life either.

Harbhajan has already felt the effect and, as he ponders over what he has done, must be aware that while he has done very well for himself financially (in spite of the huge fine!), he does not have a future outside the game. Which is why I believe that this incident, should he choose to look at it positively, could well be a blessing in disguise. He is still fairly young and if he can keep his temper in check, could emerge a better bowler. But there is another candidate on the horizon and he needs to be checked now.

Readers of this column know of my fondness for Sreesanth. I find him naïve, gullible, obsessed with fame, a touch stupid at times, but possessed of the finest outswinger I have seen for a very long time. He is a young man full of spirit but, as I have now discovered, not too popular with either his team mates or the opposition. To be fair, you don’t play the game to be popular but his antics have virtually eroded everybody’s patience. I even fear we are on the verge of losing a bowler who, in partnership with Ishant Sharma, could potentially form India’s finest new ball pairing. Given that, is it the BCCI’s responsibility to rein him in and show him a world beyond petulance or do they just leave it to him? Becoming a rich organisation is one thing, becoming a caring one another. The obsession with one is leaving no room for the other.

A permanent manager could play that role. A tough patriarch or a caring elder brother. But we treat the manager’s job callously. Before a manager can get to know a player, the tour is over, another favour has been ticked off and new favour-mongering starts. The frivolousness with which the manager’s role has been treated is an indicator of priorities. A good manager can play a huge role in the development of young minds.

Finally, I notice that the ICC elite panel of umpires has two more names in it, neither of which is Indian. I am not surprised. One of our higher ranked umpires recently allowed four short pitched balls over shoulder height in an over in a 20-20 game and another chose to speak to the media rather than to the referee. If quality has to be a hallmark of our cricket it has to extend to all facets, not just the most visible.

(Commentator Harsha Bhogle is an advisor for the Mumbai Indians team)

Ads by Google
Rate this article
 
Post Comment :
Name * Message *
Email ID *
Subject *
TERMS OF USE:
The views represented here are not neccesarily endorsed by www.expressindia.com and its allied websites. All messages will be moderated and no message that has inflammatory, abusive, derogatory language or any language deemed unfit for publication by the editor will be displayed. Though it will be endeavoured that as many messages as possible be displayed, there will be time lag between the submission and publication of the messages. The website reserves the right to publish or reject any message.
I agree to the terms of use.
  • Comments
     
Incurable Disease
by Harshad on 2008-05-11 10:30:28.100173+05:30
Harsha, this is not Hindi Philim,"Main tuze thappad marungi!" It is Kirkit!! It is a common sense. Aren't players supposed to know the ICC code of conduct? Bhajji has been playing for 10 years now, so he is supposed know atleast that physical violence is a big no no. He must sure know what happened to Shoaib when he hit Asif with a bat. Is Bhajji that dumb? If so, then he has no business playing cricket. Is he being paid to hit his opponents after loosing a match? Bhajji created big trouble and huge expense (Rs, 50 lakhs) to BCCI in the aftermath of him hitting Brett Lee's buttock with a bat, supposedly in a zest. He still did not learn from it. In the latest incident, even Bhajji said there was no provocation, so where is the question of cause and effect? Is Bhajji himself a saint when he bowls? Even if Sreesanth provoked him, Bhajji could have complained to the umpires. About educating players you are right that they need guidance and even mentoring. What are the managers and coaches doing then? Lalchand Rajput was a silent spectator when Bhajji hit Sreesanth. He should have been suspended for 5 matches atleast. Another idea would be for ICC, BCCi and IPL to make an educational videos portraying what is good conduct and what is bad conduct. There should be either some real cricketors or actors in those videos showing finer points of proper behaviour and also what can be considered poor behaviour covering multiple aspects such as behaviour with opponents, umpires, team mates,officials, media and so on.
Reply | Forword | Report Abuse
HB views on IPL
by Dilip/Hyderabad on 2008-05-10 16:06:19.38742+05:30
Hb has some very pertinent points .Definitely there should be somebody to guide these cricketers on the dos and donts of the game and other aspects of public fame.Also one fears that IPL is very interesting to watch but my personal opinion is some of the matches are being manipulated to suit some teams.Remember the spectre of match fixing has still not been eradicated and IPL involves hundred times more money than Tests or ODIs .It is hard to beleive that no match fixing attempts are not being made as newspaper reports themselves have said that tens of thousands of crores are being betted on these league matches.To think that these matches cannot be manipulated is a grave fallacy.One only hopes that with the Kind of leadership we have at the BCCI India s reputation in the long run is not harmed due to the manipulation of matches .One has to only look at the number of mistakes being made not only by indian umpires but by international renowned umpires like rudy and tiffen to see that things are not hunky dory .One only hopes that for short term view of keeping all franchises happy indias reputation is not spoiled
Reply | Forword | Report Abuse
Disease of arrogance
by gautam on 2008-05-07 22:34:41.797659+05:30
Well this so called disease is not contageous as of now and hence it has not assumed the proportion of an epidemic.In other words younger players or for that matter seniors would not try to emulate Akhtars,Bhajjis or Srees.This has something to do with pathology.Towards that direction cash rich BCCI needs to higher fulltime counsellor to educate one and all about importance of adhereing to decent behaviour on and off the field.True spirit of sportsmanship is the need of the hour.What I fear younger upcoming Indian cricketeers might fall pray to vultures(bookies) who might manupulate them to suit their demands from time to time.Unfortunately writer is advisor to Mumbai team and he could not visualise that his team has known trouble shooter who might cause endless headaches.Let me ask Harsha that has he got guts to tell Mukesh we donot need Bhajji anymore and also manager who probably instigated him to commit unacceptable act.
Reply | Forword | Report Abuse
Mentoring Cricketers.
by Dr.Madan Kandara on 2008-05-05 19:43:20.314272+05:30
Please, send me contact details of Mr. Harsha Bhogle. I may be of some help to save two fine cricketers but, poor personalities. Kind regards.Dr. Madan Kandara, MBBS, MD(Path),Grad.Cert. In Sports Med. 4/293, Maroubra Road,Maroubra, Sydney, NSW-2035 KANDARA'S LIFESTYLE SUCCESS MENTORINGS , e-mail : kandaradrm@iprimus.com.au Ph : ( 02 ) 9344 4207 ; Fax : ( 02 ) 9344 4207 Mob : 0432 169 919
Reply | Forword | Report Abuse
Disease of arrogance is taking its toll - Harsha Bhogle
by Burzin on 2008-05-02 16:59:28.369792+05:30
Harsha, It was great to read your thoughts in the article "Disease of arrogance is taking its toll". The article holds one very important lesson all of us must learn in life - humility. There are many articles surrounding this incident but no one has put in such a simple and honest way. The article outlines the crux of the problem not only in 20-20 but faced by most of us in all walks of life. I am sure the players will just benefit from reading this article and then trying to implement it. A very good example I always think of is Sachin Tendulkar who, though a genius, is so humble as a human being.
Reply | Forword | Report Abuse
Shaadi Matrimonials Get Marriage Proposals by Email EVERYDAY!
Register FREE on Naukri.com. 200000+ Hot Job Openings!
Book International flights & get 10000 Money Back
Flowers & Gifts
Send flowers & Gifts
Express Classifieds Post and view free classifieds ad
Express Astrology Know what's in the stars for you
Featured Ads
© 2008 Indian Express Newspapers (Mumbai) Ltd. All rights reserved
The Indian Express Group | Advertise With Us | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Work With Us | Site Map